How to Fix a Broken Pie Shell

eHow may earn compensation through affiliate links in this story. Learn more about our affiliate and product review process here.

Things You'll Need

  • Ice water

  • Spray bottle

  • 2 pie pans

  • Cooking spray

  • Turbinado, raw or coarse-grained sugar

Do not cry over a broken pie shell. Fix it before baking.

Do not cry over a broken pie shell. The tender, flaky texture of a well-made shell is extremely fragile and breaks happen. Luckily, a broken pie shell is easily repaired. Whether making a graham cracker crust or a traditional flaky pie shell the same method well help to seal any breaks.


Step 1

Fill a spray bottle with water and lightly spritz the top of the pie shell, especially around the broken area. Only apply a light mist of water to the pie shell to prevent it from becoming soggy.

Video of the Day

Step 2

Pinch the edges of the break together with your fingers to seal the shell.

Step 3

Transfer the pie shell to one pie pan.

Step 4

Spray the back of a second pie pan with cooking spray.

Step 5

Press the greased area of the pie plate into the pie shell so the two pie pans are nested inside each other with the pie shell between. Press evenly on the top pie pan to flatten the pie crust in the bottom pan and seal any cracks that might have occurred during transfer of the pie crust to the pan.


Step 6

Remove the top pie pan. Lightly sprinkle a thin, even layer of turbinado over the pie shell inside the pan and bake or fill and bake as directed in your recipe.


Video of the Day

references & resources

Report an Issue

screenshot of the current page

Screenshot loading...