How to Make Dreidel Cake Pops

Spinning a dreidel is a fun Hanukkah tradition, and making these dreidel cake pops could be the newest tradition in your family. Resembling dreidels with their four sides, each with a different Hebrew letter, you can actually play with the cake pops. However, everyone will much prefer eating them.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Things You'll Need

  • White or yellow cake

  • Knife

  • Vanilla frosting

  • 1-inch scoop

  • Blue candy melts

  • Vegetable shortening

  • 6-inch treat sticks

  • White fondant

  • Fondant roller

  • Knife

  • Blue candy decorating pen

  • Edible adhesive

  • Small paintbrush

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Tip

If you keep kosher, there are many brands like Wilton, Satin Ice and Betty Crocker that offer kosher choices.

Step 1: Prepare the Cake

Bake a cake either from scratch or with a box mix. I used a yellow cake box mix. After it has cooled, take a knife and cut out the sides and top sections that have browned. (You can nibble on them while you're making the cake pops.) Your cake pops will be more uniform in look and texture by using just the inside part of the cake.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 2: Crumble the Cake

Use your fingers to crumble the cake into small pieces in a bowl.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 3: Mix With Frosting

Add two heaping tablespoons of vanilla frosting to the crumbled cake. For convenience, I used a tub of frosting from the store rather than making my own.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Mix the frosting and cake until it has the consistency of cookie dough. If you need to add more frosting as you mix, do so in small one-teaspoon increments. Chill the mixture in the refrigerator for 15 minutes to make it more firm.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 4: Shape the Mixture

Scoop out some of the cake mixture with a 1-inch scoop. Using a scoop will help you make all your dreidels the same size.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Shape the mixture into a rectangular prism using your fingers, leveling the sides on the tabletop.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Pinch one end to make it pointy like the bottom of a dreidel.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Place the dreidels on a parchment-lined cookie sheet and chill in the refrigerator for 15 minutes.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 5: Prepare the Candy Melts

While the dreidels are chilling in the refrigerator, pour a bag of blue candy melts into a microwave-safe bowl.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Heat the candy melts in the microwave in 30-second intervals, stirring after each round in the microwave. Also mix two teaspoons of vegetable shortening with the candy melts to thin it out. You want the candy melts to drip from a spoon that's dipped into it.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 6: Prepare the Handle

Dip a 6-inch treat stick about a half inch into the candy melts.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Remove the dreidels from the refrigerator. Insert the dipped treat stick into the top of a dreidel. The candy around the stick will solidify when cooled and lock in the treat stick.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Poke the end of the treat stick into a piece of styrofoam to allow the cake pops to stand upright.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 7: Coat the Dreidels

Dip the dreidels in the candy melts, turning them to coat all four sides and the top.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Tap the stick against the rim of the bowl to shake off excess melted candy. Rotate the stick as you tap it so an equal amount of melted candy is removed from all four sides.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Tip

Now, while the candy melts are still liquid, would be a good time to add sprinkles if you want to give the cake pops some "bling." I ultimately decided against sprinkles because it became too ungapatchka, my favorite Yiddish term, meaning too over-decorated.

Let the cake pops stand upright in the styrofoam to allow the candy coating to harden.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 8: Roll the Fondant

Knead a ball of white fondant to soften it, and place it on a piece of parchment paper.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Flatten it with a fondant roller, making it as thin as possible. If your fondant roller has guides, use the guide for the thinnest depth.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 9: Cut Fondant

Measure the size of your dreidels. Cut squares of fondant using a knife, making them smaller than one side of a dreidel. The ones in this example were about 3/4 inches.

Tip

Let the fondant air dry for about 15 minutes before cutting them. Dried fondant is easier to handle without stretching.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

You'll need four squares of fondant for each dreidel.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 10: Draw Hebrew Letters

A dreidel has four Hebrew letters on the four sides — נ (nun), ג (gimel), ה (hei), and ש (shin). Draw one letter on each of the fondant squares with a blue candy decorating pen.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Step 11: Glue Fondant to Dreidel

Squeeze some edible adhesive onto a plate. Dip a small paintbrush in the adhesive, and apply a thin coating of the adhesive onto the back of the fondant.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Position the fondant squares on each of the four sides of the dreidel, making sure to have a different Hebrew letter on each side. The white rectangles help delineate the shape of the dreidels and stand out nicely from the blue background.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong

Be sure to make a big batch of these dreidel cake pops. If they last more than eight nights, it really will be a Hanukkah miracle.

Image Credit: Jonathan Fong