Some employers use personality tests such as the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator personality assessment tool, the NEO-Personality Inventory or the Personality Characteristics Inventory to better understand personality traits of job candidates. Advocates say workplace personality tests help employers screen out applicants who might be a bad fit for the job. Opponents argue that the tests typecast people, lack credibility and invade applicants' privacy.
Personality tests are a legal way for employers to screen job candidates and uncover possible behavior issues, such as tardiness, violence or dishonesty, reports former English professor Susan Stabile in the University of Pennsylvania Journal of Labor and Employment Law.pdf). In 1988, federal law banned the use of lie detector tests by employers, so personality tests became the next best option. The tests examine five key traits -- emotional stability, extroversion, cooperation, open-mindedness and scrupulousness -- according to Cornell University.
Advocates argue that personality tests help employers conduct more robust job interviews. Hiring managers have a better idea of what to address, such as a candidate's soft skills like troubleshooting, problem-solving, time management, self-confidence, flexibility, organization, communication and work ethic, suggests the human resources consulting firm Helios HR. They help employers understand what motivates job candidates and determine whether they're team players.
Labels and Typecasts
Opponents argue that workplace personality tests typecast individuals, resulting in unfair speculations and expectations, suggests Lily Garcia, employment law and human resources specialist, in an article in The Washington Post. Job applicants might feel trapped or limited by their personality results or fear they'll experience discrimination. For example, an applicant who tests as an introvert might not get a sales job, even though she has the education, skills, experience and previous results to back her qualifications. Some applicants say that the tests invade their privacy because they must answer personal questions that have little or nothing to do with work responsibilities.
Unreliable and Unproven
Some who oppose the tests argue that they're unreliable and untrustworthy. For example, job applicants may fake their answers and lie to make themselves look better, according to Cornell University. Workplace personality tests may not accurately assess how successful or productive a job candidate will be. According to a 2007 study at Michigan State University, business professor Frederick Morgeson determined that there was a near zero correlation between personality tests and job success rates -- 0.03 to 0.15. Personality tests also take time to conduct and interpret, and cost between $100 and $5,000 per candidate, according to Helios HR.
- University of Pennsylvania Journal of Labor and Employment Law -- Vol. 4:2: The Use of Personality Tests as a Hiring Tool -- Is the Benefit Worth the Cost?; Susan Stabile
- The Washington Post: Weighing the Pros and Cons of Taking a Personality Test at Work; Lily Garcia
- Cornell University HR Review: Personality Tests in Employment Selection -- Use With Caution
- Michigan State University: Personnel Psychology -- Are We Getting Fooled Again? Coming to Terms With Limitations in the Use of Personality Tests for Personnel Selection; Frederick Morgeson
- Helios HR: Pros Vs. Cons of Personality Assessments for Hiring and Team Development
- Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology: Types of Employment Tests
- Photo Credit michelar/iStock/Getty Images
The Advantages of Type A Personalities
Typically described as competitive, no-nonsense, temperamental and having a sense of urgency, Type A personalities run in overdrive. Considered the "go-getters," they...
Advantages of the Scientific Selection of Employees
Businesses of all sizes struggle to recruit, hire and hold onto the best employees. The majority of human resources professionals treat employee...
Advantages & Disadvantages of a Projective Test
Projective tests are measures used and developed by psychologists. These tests are considered "projective" because they involve showing a picture or other...
Advantages and Disadvantages of Selection and Recruitment
A human resources department is in charge of the perpetual recruiting of new employees, and has a significant hand in the candidate...
The Advantages of Self Assessment
People may consider performing self-evaluations for any number of reasons. For instance, some people may wish to determine their personality type. Various...
The Disadvantages of Intelligence Testing
Intelligence tests are designed to measure mental capacity, function and intellectual skills such as reasoning and understanding. For years, intelligence test results...
Advantages & Disadvantages of Self Assessment
A self assessment aims to help a person identify his own areas of strengths and weakness to create an action plan for...