Thrift institutions and commercial banks are different financial entities with different models of funding and reasons for existence. As the modern banking system has matured, the differences between the two models has become more acute. Thrift organizations continue predominantly to supply mortgages to local communities funded by their savings, while commercial banks have diversified into riskier areas of investment but continue to supply loans to businesses.
Thrift institutions are mainly funded by savings deposited by individuals and local businessed for which they are paid interest much like building societies in the U.K. and Australia. They are much smaller than commercial banks, operate locally and do not rely on the money markets or private equity for funding. The money paid in by the local community is loaned in the form of mortgages and personal loans. Commercial banks have been free to behave in much the same way as investment banks since the Glass-Steagall Act of 1932, which no longer required retail banks to be separate from investment banks.
Thrift institutions come in two forms, savings-and-loan associations and savings banks. They are mutually owned by their customers who have voting rights and the ability to influence the financial and managerial direction of the institution as opposed to commercial banks, which are owned by shareholders. Some commercial banks are privately held, but most of the world's largest commercial banks have shares publicly traded on stock exchanges.
Thrift institutions in the U.S. where established in the 1850s under federal control and are more heavily regulated than the commercial banks. They must have at least 65 percent of their lending in consumer mortgages and loans by law and are particularly vulnerable to downturns in the housing market as a consequence. Although thrifts were hit hard during the 2008 banking crisis, they have proved durable as they were not exposed to some of the more exotic debt that commercial banks had on their books at the time of the slump.
- Photo Credit Pennies on the Dollar - one dollar bill with pennies. image by Andy Dean from Fotolia.com
Savings Banks Vs. Commercial Banks
The term "bank" is applied to a variety of financial intermediaries. The financial intermediary matches suppliers of capital to invest against those...
What Is the Difference Between an Investment Bank & a Commercial Bank?
A commercial bank takes deposits and issues loans to customers. An investment bank sells securities, investment instruments and provides advice on buyouts...
What Is the Difference Between a Commercial Bank and a Savings & Loan Bank?
A commercial bank and a savings and loan institution are similar in that they both accept deposits and make loans. Each type...
Difference Between a Bank and a Savings and Loan
Banks and savings and loan associations differ primarily in that separate government bodies regulate the two institutions. Most of the differences between...
How to Tell The Difference Between Consignment and Thrift Stores
A number of people do not understand the difference between thrift shops and consignment shops. Please read on to give you some...
What Is the Meaning of Thrift Bank?
A thrift bank, or thrift, is a term for a financial service organization that specializes in offering savings accounts and originating mortgage...
What Is the Difference Between an Investment Bank & a Bank Holding Company?
Bank holding companies and investment banks are distinctly different entities that serve separate purposes. A bank holding company controls or owns one...