Pan-frying and grilling are distinct cooking methods used to cook a wide range of foods, including meat, fish and vegetables. Unlike grilling, pan-frying requires a fat such as oil or butter, which can add to the calorie content of your meal. Grilling has its own health risks, such as potential exposure to hydrocarbons in smoke. Each method produces different flavors and textures that you should consider when deciding which one to use.
Pan-frying means cooking food in just enough oil or butter and lightly frying it on each side. Before placing the food in the pan, heat the oil or butter at a high temperature until it is just starting to smoke. The food should sizzle immediately in the pan, at which point you can lower the heat to medium high. Pan frying often involves dredging the food in a coating before frying it. You may need to flip the food a few times before it is slightly brown and crispy. Grilling requires a barbecue and usually takes longer than pan-frying. Heating up the barbecue can take 15 minutes or more, depending on the heat source, but once you place the food on the grill you’ll probably only need to flip it once or twice. Different foods require different grilling techniques, so consult the recipe to determine the recommended approach.
Flavor and Texture
Pan-frying and grilling produce different results in terms of flavor and texture. Many cooks prefer grilling for meat dishes such as hamburgers, steaks or kebabs because of the smoky flavor and charred texture achieved with this method. Pan-frying allows you to retain the meat’s natural juices, which can be used to make a sauce or gravy. In general, pan-frying will give your food a crispy texture that can be greasy, while grilling tends to produce food with a dry, coarse exterior.
Grilling and pan-frying are both associated with health concerns that apply to cooking meat and fish at high temperatures. According to Kansas State University, grilled and pan-fried meat can result in the formation of heterocylic amines, or HCA, a chemical compound believed to cause certain types of cancer. Grilling meat on the barbecue is especially risky because it can cause another cancer-causing agent called polycyclic aromatichydrocarbons, or PAH, to form in the smoke produced by dripping fat. One benefit to grilling is that the fat from meat drips off into the barbecue rather than being absorbed along with the oil or butter, as with pan-frying.
Convenience and Flexibility
In many ways pan-frying is more convenient and flexible than grilling. While pan-frying can be done throughout the year, grilling is an outdoor activity that requires decent weather. Grilling also requires that you transport food and kitchen items in and out of the house, which can be a hassle. Cleaning the grill before and after the meal is also more time-consuming than washing a single frying pan, and grilling also has limitations in terms of what you can cook. For example, certain fish, such as tuna, swordfish and salmon, are fine for the grill, but light, flaky fish is much easier to pan-fry. Large vegetables like eggplant and corn work well on the grill, but pan-frying is the way to go if you’re cooking small or chopped vegetables.
- Photo Credit John Foxx/Stockbyte/Getty Images