Pesky biting insects can force even the most ambitious gardeners back indoors. By appealing to consumers' appetite for environmentally friendly, nonchemical products, manufacturers advertise ultrasonic devices as a safe way to keep bugs away while working outdoors. Sound frequency devices, however, do not repel insects. Unfortunately, good marketing strategies often trump sound science when it comes to repelling insects.
Manufacturers promote their ultrasonic devices by claiming the machines protect people from insect-borne diseases such as West Nile virus that lurk in gardens and other outdoor spaces. Taking advantage of many humans' aversion to chemicals, they market their products as a better alternative than insect repellent chemicals, including DEET. Based on the principle that insects locate mates or avoid predatory insects by the sound of beating wings, the machines supposedly mimic the frequency of wing beats and cause biting insects to avoid the location of the sound.
Various scientific studies have proven that ultrasonic insect repellent devices do not repel insects. From as early as 1985, the U.S. Federal Trade Commission has issued warnings to and brought legal action against manufacturers and sellers of the devices, indicating that advertising claims must be supported by scientific evidence. Staying well covered, removing nearby standing water and using a repellent containing DEET are the best ways to avoid insect bites when working in your garden.
- Rutgers School of Environmental and Biological Sciences: Products and Promotions That Have Limited Value for Mosquito Control
- University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension, Lancaster County: Considering Ultrasonic Pest-Control Devices? Save Your Money
- U.S. Federal Trade Commission: FTC Warns Manufacturers and Retailers of Ultrasonic Pest-Control Devices
- U.S. Federal Trade Commission: FTC Alleges Electronic Mosquito Repellent Claims Are False
- American Mosquito Control Association: Frequently Asked Questions -- Do Ultrasonic Devices Work?
- U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: CDC Health Information for International Travel -- Chapter 2
- Photo Credit Vitalii Hulai/iStock/Getty Images
Mosquito Frequency Repellent
For people who don't like to use chemicals to repel mosquitoes, frequency repellents seem to provide a good solution. These electronic devices...
How to Repel Flies at a BBQ
Flies, bees, ants and other insects are attracted to the abundance of meat and sugar present at a barbecue. Repelling the flies...
How Effective Are Electronic Insect Repellents?
Electronic insect repellents that utilize electromagnetic, sonic and/or ultrasonic energy are devices marketed to attract customers who want to keep the insects...
Plug-in Devices to Keep Mice and Bugs Out of Your House
Several types of plug-in devices claim to repel rodent and insects, using high-frequency sound waves or vibrations. They are often promoted as...