Classroom debates give students the opportunity to focus solely on one side of an issue or topic. In addition to providing opportunity for research, debates develop public speaking and presentation skills. To organize a classroom debate, provide students with guidelines for topics, arguments and the courtesy required in debating a classmate.
Common Courtesy During Debate
Debates often focus on controversial topics that students may feel passionately about, so courtesy and respect for all opinions should be encouraged. To introduce the idea of courtesy, explain to students that debate questions often do not have a "right" or "wrong" answer and that critical thinking develops when different ideas are present. For example, set ground rules for interrupting, raised voices and personal attacks before starting the debate. The High School Public Debate Program allows heckling limited to a single word or phrase directed at the judges. However, interruptions or exclamations that disrupt the speaker or are excessively rude are not allowed. The penalty for breaking rules in competitive debate include taking a loss, having to repeat the debate or a reprimand.
Rules for Topics
Rules for choosing topics attempt to ensure that both the pro and con sides of the subject can be researched. In classroom debates, teachers provide the topics, often based on the class subject. For example, in an English class, students may debate whether fate actually guides the human experience after reading Oedipus Rex. In a history class, students may debate the merits of war, while a science class may debate the ethics of bioengineering. When choosing topics for the classroom, teachers should take into account the political climate of the school as well as the maturity and sensitivity of the students involved. Teachers should also avoid topics that reveal personal bias or may easily lead to attacks on individual students.
Argument and Proof
With an assigned topic, both the pro and con sides in the debate should begin to research evidence for their side of the argument. Debaters should use both facts and opinions in the presentation of their argument. Students should also research the opposing side and perform a critical analysis to decide which facts and opinions of the other side will be used in the rebuttal stage. In competitive debate, the use of electronics during debate is not allowed, but classroom debates may allow this. Evidence should be in the form of facts, not other speeches or opinions, and the first mention of evidence should include a complete citation -- author, title, date of publication and page number.
Rules for Speakers
To ensure that all opinions are heard, develop a format for engaging in debate and introduce the format to the students before the debate. For example, the debate may include two rounds of discussion in which the first side presents the "pro" side immediately followed by the team with the "con" side. The second round will allow the "pro" side to respond to the "con" arguments of the first round. Create time limits for each side that are clear and carefully adhered to. For example, give each side a two-minute limit to present its case.
- Proquest; Teacher Mini-Debate Guide; 2007
- McGraw Hill; Using Taking Sides in the Classroom; 2009
- Northwest Association for Biomedical Research; Debate
- High School Public Debate Program: Rules
- California High School Speech Association: Article XI: The State Tournament --Debate Rules
- California High School Speech Association: Judging Criteria -- Team Debate
- Photo Credit Brad Calkins/iStock/Getty Images
How to Hold a Classroom Debate
Classroom debates can be a very lively and engaging way for students to discuss important issues and develop as thinkers and communicators....
How to Conduct a Classroom Debate
Holding a classroom debate is an effective way to improve the speaking, researching, reading, writing, reasoning and persuasion skills of your students....
Debate Rules & Techniques
Debate, in an academic sense, is a disciplined form of arguing toward a person or team of people. A debater must provide...
Fun Classroom Debate Games
Debates provide excellent classroom learning opportunities. They help students learn how to think critically, express viewpoints rationally and reflect upon the views...
Rules for How to Judge Debates
Competitive debate is a tool for teaching students to speak in public, think critically and prepare coherent arguments. The activity relies on...