How Does Being an Independent Contractor Affect Unemployment?
A true independent contractor is unable to receive unemployment compensation because a true independent contract was never "employed" in the first place. However, unemployment compensation law is fairly liberal with the distinction between employees and independent contractors. Many people labeled as independent contractors may still be treated as employees, at least in the realm of unemployment compensation.
Other People Are Reading
-
Legal Background
-
Unemployment compensation, or unemployment insurance, is a general requirement of U.S. federal law, but each state's laws also play a role in defining the terms of unemployment within that state. The interplay between federal and state rules can create some confusion, and it also creates some inconsistency in the rules depending on whether you live in one state or another state. The detailed rules regarding independent contractors vary among the states, although the general rules remain fairly constant.
Labels
-
Many employers attempt to label their employees as independent contractors. Employers benefit from labeling their workforce as independent contractors because employers have less legal liability in connection with independent contractors, and they also have less tax liability for independent contractors. The law does not always respect the label given by employers. Instead, the law looks at the reality of each relationship to determine whether an employment relationship existed.
-
Undefined Territory
-
Unemployment compensation law requires an examination of the facts in each relationship. The substance of the relationship is what matters, not the labels. Because of this fact-intensive analysis, it is not always easy to determine whether a person is an employee or a true independent contractor. Your unemployment office makes the final decision after reviewing the circumstances of your employment relationship.
Indicators
-
The unemployment office examines a few key indicators when determining whether you are actually an independent contractor. If you are under the direct supervision of your employer, then you are probably not an independent contractor. Similarly, if you work at the employer's office, or use the employer's equipment, then you are probably not an independent contractor. Finally, if your work for the employer is a regular and consistent part of the employer's business operations, rather than an isolated or sporadic interaction, then you may not be an independent contractor. On the other hand, if you are involved for a discrete project, you are paid a flat fee or commission, you work from your own location and with your own equipment, and you are not under direct day-to-day supervision, then you will probably be considered an independent contractor and therefore not be eligible for unemployment insurance.
-
References
- Photo Credit Jupiterimages/Comstock/Getty Images
