A survey reported in 2014 by the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners determined that the typical organization loses 5 percent of revenues each year to occupational fraud, which includes employee theft and embezzlement. Although every business owner has the right to investigate and deal with instances that may arise, an accused employee also has certain constitutional rights. Understanding these rights is vital to conducting a fair and legal theft investigation, as well as avoiding redress actions.
The Right to Avoid Self-Incriminating Statements
The Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which applies to both civil and criminal matters, says that an accused person has the right to avoid self-incrimination. This means that although an employer can ask a question such as “Did you take money from the register?,” you cannot force an employee to answer. On the other hand, an employee cannot refuse to participate in a theft investigation. This means you can say “You have the right to refuse to answer this question but face immediate termination if you refuse.”
The Right to Refuse a Polygraph
The Employee Polygraph Protection Act of 1988 says that an employee of a private company has the right to refuse to take a polygraph test except during a workplace investigation of an economic loss to the employer by an employee who had access to the property stolen. This limited exception requires that the employer is reasonably sure the employee committed the act and does not require the employee to submit to a deceptograph, voice stress analyzer or psychological stress evaluation. If you do, potential redress actions include equitable reliefs such as reinstatement, promotion and payment of lost wages and benefits.
The Right to Review Records
State laws determine whether an employee has the right to review documents used in an internal investigation. For example, in Wisconsin, an employee has the right to review general employment records, as well as documents used in termination proceedings or other disciplinary actions. However, this right does not extend to records pertaining to a possible criminal investigation or a judicial proceeding. In contrast, in Illinois, as soon as an employer files legal charges based on security records, an employee has the right of review. Review state laws carefully, as violations can lead to monetary penalties that increase each day an employer is in violation. Check the website of your state's labor or workforce development department for current labor laws and regulations.
About Privacy Rights
Although an employee in general has few privacy rights in the workplace, there are some gray areas. For example, while the employer has the right to monitor computer usage and most employee activities, employees have the right to expect privacy when it comes to their bodies. Nolo.com recommends that you involve the police before conducting a body search, as privacy law violations can leave an employer open to monetary and criminal penalties.
- Cornell University Law School Legal Information Institute: Bill of Rights
- Florida Department of Law Enforcement: Criminal vs. Administrative Investigations
- U.S. Department of Labor: Fact Sheet #36: Employee Polygraph Protection Act of 1988
- New Jersey Law Blog: Recent Case Law Under the Employee Polygraph Protection Act: A Practical Review
- State of Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development: Records Open to Employees
- Illinois Association of School Boards: Personnel Records: Understanding the Implementation of the Illinois Personnel Records Review Act
- Nolo: Workplace Searches: Dos and Don'ts
- Cornell University Law School Legal Information Institute: 32 CFR 505.12 - Privacy Act Enforcement Actions
- Photo Credit Catherine Yeulet/iStock/Getty Images
What to Do if You Are Accused of Workplace Harassment
Being accused of harassment in the workplace is a serious matter. According to the U.S. Department of Transportation's "Sexual Harassment Fact Sheet,"...
How to Question an Employee About Embezzlement
If you notice a discrepancy in your company's books and suspect an employee of stealing, you must know the proper way to...
How to Terminate an Employee in California
As California is an at-will employment state, you theoretically can fire anyone at any time for any reason. In practice, however, the...
How Should a Company Terminate Employees Caught Stealing?
In general, employers have broad authority to fire workers at any time for any reason, as long as the firing doesn't violate...
Termination Process for a Dishonest Employee
The procedures involved in terminating a dishonest employee are not unlike the methods for terminating honest employees. What differentiates the termination procedure...
Workplace Theft Policies
Employee theft is a problem at many companies. It can be as simple as including adding unworked hours to a time sheet...
What to Do if Falsely Accused of Something in the Workplace
Workplace gossip can be fleeting and harmless, but certain kinds of gossip can harm your reputation and your career. Your company will...
Employer-Employee Ethical Issues
Problematic situations in the workplace can involve ethical violations by employers against employees, by employees against employers, or by both in collaboration...