Trying to use retirement assets as collateral or security for a loan has two major problems. First, the Internal Revenue Service expressly forbids it in the case of IRAs, Roth IRAs and IRA-based retirement plans. Second, lenders are reluctant to lend against retirement plans when much of the plan receives protection against creditors that would make it difficult or even impossible for them to collect the collateral if the loan were not repaid.
You may not borrow from an IRA or any IRA-based plan, nor may you pledge the IRA as collateral for a loan. If you do, the Internal Revenue Service will disallow the entire IRA, and deem you to have taken a distribution. This distribution would be fully taxable as income, and come with an additional 10 percent penalty if you are under age 59 1/2.
If your employer plan allows it, you can borrow from a 401(k). In this case, you call or write the 401(k) plan administrator. They send you a check, and you pay your own 401(k) plan back with interest. The remainder of the 401(k) balance serves as collateral for the loan.
Disadvantages of Borrowing Against a 401(k)
When you borrow against a 401(k), you must pay yourself back with after-tax money, even though you borrowed before tax money. The money you use to repay a loan will be subject to tax again when you take it out in retirement. This would, in effect, subject that portion of your 401(k) to double taxation. In addition, if you have a loan outstanding with your 401(k) and you lose your job, you may have to pay back the entire loan immediately. If you do not, the IRS will deem you to have taken a distribution and hit you with income tax and a 10 penalty if you are under age 59 1/2.
A margin loan is a loan from a broker, using your account as collateral. However, since the IRS does not allow you to use a retirement account as collateral for a loan, you will not be able to open up a margin account using your retirement assets as collateral. You must open an account separate from your retirement accounts and use that as collateral instead.
Can an IRA Be a Margin Account?
Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) are tax-favored investment structures that must follow the regulations set forth by the IRS. For many investors, IRAs...
How to Use Collateral
Collateral is a powerful asset that, if used properly, can enable a borrower to secure a loan with attractive terms. Collateral is...
How to Use an IRA Account As Collateral
For many people, retirement assets may be the largest source of funds. When seeking a unsecured loan, it can be very attractive...
Can Pensions Be Used as Collateral?
A person seeking a loan might be required to provide collateral — usually a non-cash asset — to secure the loan. This...
Can I Borrow Money From My Mutual Funds?
If you need a loan but don't have a house, you may look at your mutual funds as collateral. The type of...
Can a Roth IRA Be Used as Collateral?
Internal Revenue Service rules are very clear: you cannot use your Roth Individual Retirement Account as collateral on a loan. Should you...
Can I Use a Mutual Fund As Collateral?
A mutual fund is an arrangement between investors who pool their money and hire a professional money manager to invest it. Mutual...