Mentoring is a personal development tool in which a less experienced professional seeks the advice, counsel and support of an experienced professional. Unlike training, which is done by a supervisor or trainer as part of a mandatory skills education program, mentoring is a relationship between two people in the same profession, with one person taking the role of teacher and the other taking the role of student.
The main difference between mentoring and training is the nature of the relationship involved. A mentor-mentee relationship is personal, confidential and friendly; a trainer-trainee relationship is impersonal, social and hierarchical. Typically, one mentor is responsible for one mentee, whereas one trainer may be responsible for an entire group of students. The result is that a mentoring relationship is much more intimate than a training relationship.
Motivation is a major objective in mentoring. This is not necessarily the case in training. Though a mentor is responsible for dispensing valuable lessons to his mentee, he is also expected to provide encouragement and support. A trainer, on the other hand, is expected to deliver a content-based lesson as effectively as possible. A trainer could become a motivating force in his students' lives, but it is not necessarily a priority for him to do so.
The role of advice is another difference between mentoring and training. In mentoring, advice is long-term, practical counsel intended to help the mentee reach her long term goals. In training, advice is limited to points of guidance pertaining to the execution of specific duties. Mentors provide career advice; trainers provide job advice.
Mentoring is typically longer in duration than training. A mentoring relationship may last months or even years, but a training session typically lasts no longer than a few weeks. Of course, this depends on the industry in which the mentors and trainers work. In some fields, such as policing, training takes the form of long-term academy curriculum, in which trainers may supervise trainees for more than a year.
The benefits of mentoring and training are quite different. Mentoring provides mentors and mentees with mutual support; the mentor gets a sense of satisfaction from being seen as a source of wisdom, while the mentee gets invaluable advice and a go-to person with whom to discuss challenges and setbacks. Training generally provides a simpler kind of support; the trainer gets the pleasure of teaching and instructing, and the trainee gets practical know-how.
- Photo Credit teacher & students image by Luisafer from Fotolia.com
Difference Between CNA & HHA Training
The duties of a CNA (certified nursing assistant) and an HHA (home health aide) are similar. There are subtle differences, however, in...
The Difference Between Teaching & Training
Teaching and training may be thought of as the same thing, but they, in fact, have many differences. While they are both...
What Is the Difference Between a Tailor and a Seamstress?
Tailor and seamstress are two different job titles that are often used interchangeably. Many of the requirements of the two occupations overlap,...
The Difference Between a Master of Education Degree and a Master in the Art of Teaching
A Master of Education degree and a Master in the Art of Teaching degree are comparable in their educational focus. The subject...
What Is the Difference Between an Intern & an Extern?
According to Merriam-Webster, both "intern" and "extern" refer to job positions that students and recent graduates take on to gain experience and...
Relationship Between Leaders and Mentors
Having a mentor can make a big difference in your career success. Although mentors often have formal leadership roles, mentoring is not...
The Differences Between a Coach and a Mentor
Coaching and mentoring are both important roles in a person's life. Many people need guidance and help to achieve a certain goal...