Situational Leadership Pro & Cons

Save

Situational leadership theory encourages leaders to adapt their leadership style based on the difficulty of the task and the maturity of the team member. Relationships play a key role. In the Hersey-Blanchard situational leadership model, "maturity" refers to both psychological and job maturity with an assumption that job skill level matches psychological maturity. This tenet has generated debate about the pros and cons of situational leadership.

Characteristics of Situational Leadership

  • Hersey and Blanchard espouse four leadership styles: telling/directing, selling/coaching, participating/coaching and delegating/observing. These styles represent decreasing levels of leader direction and increasing focus on leader-follower relationships, starting with heavy focus on providing direction, then coaching, sharing decision-making, and allowing subordinates to create solutions for issues identified by the leader. Leaders move from one style to another based on the situation, task and maturity of the follower.

Positive Aspects of Situational Leadership

  • Situational leadership has advantages in terms of ease of use and simplicity. It recognizes the need for flexibility on the part of leaders and the importance of the followers as determinants of leader behavior. It also has intuitive appeal.

Drawbacks of Situational Leadership

  • The situational leadership model has a North American bias that neglects the way other cultures communicate and prioritize values such as individualism and family. This model may also ignore differences between female managers who typically have a nurturing style, and male leaders who may lean toward a task-oriented management style.

    Situational leadership can divert leaders' focus away from long-term strategies, symbols, structure or politics.

    Critics of situational leadership point to the difficulty in defining and quantifying maturity, who should rate it, and the tendency to assume that job maturity matches emotional maturity. Hersey and Blanchard define job maturity as "ability to take responsibility" but do not provide a credible source to support that definition.

    Situational leadership focuses on follower maturity as a key determinant of the leader's focus on tasks over relationships. This view conflicts with other leadership models that embrace numerous situational factors as determinants of numerous leader behaviors such as providing support and direction, participation and focus on follower achievements. In the other leadership models, situational factors include relationships between leaders and followers, position power and the structure of the task.

    The Hersey-Blanchard model also ignores interpersonal relationships within work groups that can have a negative impact on performance.

Contemporary Leadership Theory

  • In a world of globalization where the rate of change escalates, leadership models continue to evolve toward team approaches, employee empowerment and continuous learning. Relationships between leaders and followers continue to play a significant role in the effectiveness and outcomes of the work produced. Aside from relationships, tasks and outcomes, other factors such as responsible and ethical exercise of power have become topics of discussion regarding effective leadership.

References

  • Photo Credit handsome managers image by Andrey Kiselev from Fotolia.com
Promoted By Zergnet

Comments

Resources

You May Also Like

  • Pros & Cons of Organizational Leadership

    In both the private and public sector, organizational leadership is a very complex element to the structure of any agency or company....

  • Advantages of Situational Leadership

    Situational leadership is the dominant theory upon which supervisory-level leadership training worldwide today is based. Groundbreaking in its suggestion that managers should...

  • Definition of Situational Leadership

    Those who serve in leadership positions develop an individual philosophy on how to lead their organization. Personal approaches to leadership are constantly...

  • What Is Contingency & Situational Leadership?

    Contingency theory and the situational leadership model offer two ways to look at a manager's role in an organization. Managers make decisions...

  • Critique of Leadership Styles

    Some people are born leaders, while others learn their leadership skills. Either way, leadership style is driven at least in part by...

  • Description of Leadership Effectiveness & Adaptability

    A person develops leadership effectiveness and adaptability skills over time. Leaders can compare their behavior to the Situational Leadership Model, a resource...

  • Two Theories of Leadership

    Various methods have influenced leaders' approaches in dealing with subordinates. However, two theories have greatly affected leaders' behaviors. The situational and transformational...

  • Pros & Cons of Team Leadership Styles

    In 2005, leadership expert John Maxwell identified influence as the true measure of leadership. The role of a leader is, ultimately, to...

  • Advantages and Disadvantages of Leadership Models

    Leadership models are approaches structured to provide effective guidance and decision-making expertise within an organization. Each person has a different style of...

Related Searches

Check It Out

Are You Really Getting A Deal From Discount Stores?

M
Is DIY in your DNA? Become part of our maker community.
Submit Your Work!