Can You Claim Unemployment if You Work as a Consultant & Are Let Go?
An employer and worker should both understand the legal and financial consequences of hiring the worker as a consultant. If the employer ends the working relationship with a consultant, the worker might want to claim unemployment benefits. A successful claim might provide much-needed financial help while the worker searches for new jobs. Whether the consultant qualifies as an employee instead of an independent contractor, often affects the employer's obligations and the worker's right to claim unemployment.
Other People Are Reading
-
Employer's Obligation to Pay Unemployment
-
In general, an employer with employees must pay taxes into the state's unemployment insurance program. When an employer terminates an employment arrangement, an employee has a right to file a claim with the state's unemployment agency. Each state pays workers' benefits from money collected through employers' contributions to the unemployment insurance program. When an employer hires the worker as a consultant, however, the worker's right to claim unemployment depends on whether the consultant is an employee or independent contractor. Some states specifically deny unemployment benefits to independent contractors. Employers might choose to hire workers as independent contractors because state and federal employment laws often allow employers to bypass the insurance and benefits requirements that they would otherwise need to pay on behalf of employees.
Consultant as Employee
-
Some consultants know they are employees, and therefore, are likely to qualify for benefits if their employment ends in one of the ways permitted by their state's criteria for unemployment compensation. A consultant might be an employee if he works as a management consultant, also known as a management analyst. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, consultants work for companies that offer client services in business or technical consulting. The worker's job title and position with a consulting company might indicate that he is an employee. However, many other factors might affect whether he works as an employee rather than as an independent contractor.
-
Consultant as Independent Contractor
-
If a consultant and an employer signed an agreement stating that the consultant is an independent contractor, the agreement likely establishes the consultant's status as a self-employed worker who isn't eligible to claim unemployment. Many other factors, however, can determine whether the consultant is actually an employee. These factors generally come from each state's employment laws. The state unemployment insurance program might consider the scope of duties performed by the consultant, the authority of the consultant to manage tasks or projects autonomously, regular oversight by a supervisor with the employer, the regular types of business engaged in by the employer, method of compensation, and the duration of the consultant's working relationship with the employer.
Process for Consultant to Receive Unemployment Benefits
-
Because many factors can affect whether a consultant is an independent contractor or employee for the purpose of unemployment benefits, a consultant should contact the unemployment agency serving her state. Unemployment insurance programs often encourage workers to file claims even if they're unsure about their eligibility. An agency needs to see detailed information regarding the consultant's employment in order to determine eligibility for benefits. As part of the claim process, the consultant's employer also has an opportunity to present information about the consultant's employment and explain why the employer treated the consultant like an independent contractor. The consultant's claim might proceed to a hearing on eligibility for unemployment. Furthermore, if the program denies the consultant's claim, the consultant might be able to appeal depending on the laws of the state. In these situations, the consultant might need to consult an attorney.
-
References
- Lawyers.com: Unemployment Benefits
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics: Management Analysts
- Executive Office of Labor and Workforce Development: Unemployment Benefits FAQs: Eligibility:
- California Department of Industrial Relations: Independent Contractors
- Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs: Independent Contractors
Resources
- Photo Credit Comstock/Comstock/Getty Images
