How to Build an Effective Case Against Dog Fighters

It is not always easy to convict someone for running a dog fight. Even though it might look obvious to you that somebody is involved in the "game" of dog fighting, it takes solid evidence to make the charges stick. That's why it is important to build an effective case against dog fighters right from the start.

Instructions

Difficulty: Moderately Challenging

1. Start by being observant and reporting what you see and hear. To be more effective against dog fighters, report anything suspicious such as blood spatters on the walls of a basement or garage or on the ground where dogs are trained or housed.
2. Look for dog fighters in rural and urban areas and from all walks of life. Dog fighting is not limited to gangs anymore. Anyone, including high-profile citizens, might be involved in dog fighting.
3. Catch dog fighters in the act. If you know of an upcoming fight or the location of one, notify police or the appropriate law enforcement so they can catch offenders while the fight is happening. This is the ideal way to begin to build a case.
4. Find proof of the act. Indisputable evidence such as photos of abused dogs or of the actual fighting are ideal. Fights are often videotaped, so obtaining a copy of the tape can really help your case.
5. Obtain sworn testimony from witnesses or individuals who actually participated in the dog fighting. Written proof with the accused dog fighter's name on it and referencing the witnesses' knowledge of the fighting are good evidence to provide the court. For instance, you could use veterinarian bills, bills for materials for building transport cages for the dogs, for supplies to build fighting pits or for implements used in training for aggression.
6. Get needed search warrants to search or seize property. Defendants in dog fighting cases often claim that their property rights were violated. This has been an effective defense, so don't give the alleged dog fighters a chance to use it.
7. Use other laws to your advantage. You might not have enough to convict dog fighters on dog-fighting charges, but they might be involved in other crimes such as illegal gambling, conspiracy, animal cruelty or exposing minors to immoral acts.

Tips & Warnings

• You can be more effective against dog fighting by educating the public about it and by supporting legislation that encourages strong penalties for people involved in dog fighting.
• Be realistic. Know that just because a person owns, raises or breeds pit bulls of other fighting breeds does not mean he is involved in dog fighting.