How to Decide Which to Pursue: a Ph.D. or D.Ed.?

By Lance Orndorff

Rate: (3 Ratings)

For many students, the choice between a Doctor of Philosophy and a Doctor of Education seems almost equal. Unfortunately, the choice becomes clear only after investing years of course work, tens of thousands of dollars and years of political maneuvering. But there are some early signs that can assist an individual in making a better choice BEFORE applying to and beginning a program.

Instructions

Difficulty: Moderate

Things You’ll Need:

  • Access to a computer
  • Telephone with hands-free speaker phone capabilities
  • Recording device
  • Two pads of paper
  • Pen
Step1
Surf the Internet to locate 10 Ph.D. in Education programs and 10 Doctor of Education Programs. Make the search close to your intended state or region of planned attendance.
Step2
Call the head of the department of each of the programs and ask if you can speak to a program advisor. Indicate that you are trying to make a choice between a Doctor of Philosophy in Education and a Doctorate in Education program.
Step3
Using the speaker phone mode, call each of the advisors and inform them that you are recording the call so that you can go back and listen to the conversation again and again for clarity. Turn on the recording device. If an advisor objects to the recording, mark him off your list and use another advisor.
Step4
Ask advisors which program they earned their degree in and which program they are an advisor for. Then ask them what, exactly, they see as the difference in the two types of programs. Inquire specifically about the capstone course, paper, dissertation, or thesis. This is often where the major differences occur. Also ask them about the program completion rates at the school.
Step5
After making all the calls and recording all the interviews, use two tablets of paper. Mark at the top of one Ph.D. and at the top of the other Doctor of Education. As you listen to each recording, over and over, make notes on either pad as appropriate listing the differences, advantages and unique characteristics of each.
Step6
For each item marked on each pad of paper, write one or two sentences of how that item may or may not match your learning style, capabilities, desired academic outcomes and career ambitions. By the time you write your final statement to the final element of the final interview, you will have done more to understand which program is best for you than 99% of the students in doctoral programs today.

Tips & Warnings

  • Allow the advisor you are interviewing to do 98% of the talking. This is a time to actively listen, not share your own views, likes or dislikes.
  • Always inform the other party that you are recording the call. It is more of an issue of ethics than of law.
  • Do not take short cuts and call less than the total 20 advisors.
  • If you cannot complete this how to from beginning to end, it is a clear sign that you will never complete a doctoral degree.

Comments

| View All Comments
Flag This Comment

on 3/4/2008 It’s been about 10 years since I've looked at the data, but I do clearly remember that the Ed.D. is earning, on average, much more than the Ph.D. Again, that is on average, someone that is exceptional will rise to the top no matter what the degree is. Prestige was never on my list of goals, it was productivity and income. If there is some relationship between prestige and those two goals, I've not made the connection. Thanks for the comments!

Joaozinho

Joaozinho said

Flag This Comment

on 3/4/2008 No phone calls are required to know that the Ph.D. degree carries more prestige than the Ed.D. degree does, especially in Liberal Arts colleges.

Post a Comment

POST A COMMENT

Request a New How-To Article

Looking for more How To information? Chances are there’s an eHow member who knows how to do what you’re looking to do. Submit an article request now!

eHow Article: How to Decide Which to Pursue: a Ph.D. or D.Ed.?

Article By: Lance Orndorff

Lance Orndorff

Novice Novice | 200 Points

Category: Education

Articles: See my other articles

Related Ads

Education

Schwengel
Meet Kurt Schwengel eHow’s Education Expert.