How to Compare Vinyl & Wood Windows

Choosing between wood and vinyl windows can be a difficult decision.

There are pros and cons to wood and vinyl windows for replacement and new construction. Consider cost, ease of use, expected length of home ownership, and the look desired when making the decision.

Wood Windows

Wood windows are popular for their natural, rich look. New wood windows are often clad on the exterior with vinyl or aluminum, but may be primed for painting. Some homeowners want the interior wood finish to match other natural wood in the house. However, wood windows are prone to rot, and interior frames must be maintained regularly with paint or varnish.

Vinyl Windows

Vinyl windows are easy to maintain and do not rot. They are readily available, and can be manufactured for any window size. The best vinyl windows have thick walls, double paned glass, flip-in features, and easy to remove screens. Look for fully welded windows with smooth connections.

Considerations

Since many modern wood windows are made with new growth pine, they are particularly susceptible to rot. Beware of replacement window contractors and compare prices--many will charge a premium for labor while installing a window available at a much lower price.

References

• Northwest Home Improvement: Vinyl Replacement Windows vs. Wood Replacement Windows
• The Garden Web: Wood vs Vinyl Windows
• Contractor Talk: Wood Vs. Vinyl