Diapers Vs. Underpads

Diapers and underpads have their pros and cons.

Parents with toddlers and little children have the choice of using diapers or a waterproof underpad to protect a baby's mattress. Opinions differ on which is better.

Diapers

Some parents prefer to use diapers because they are more comfortable for the child. Diapers absorb moisture quite effectively so the child continues sleeping even after passing urine. Diapers can be conveniently changed and easily disposed, and do not soil the child's clothes or bedding.

Underpads

Underpads may be more comfortable, particularly with older children who do not like wearing bulky diapers at night. However, with underpads, the child will probably wake up or have disturbed and uncomfortable sleep after wetting or soiling the bed. Underpads are messier and require more cleanup than diapers.

Toilet Training

Underpads may be more effective for nighttime toilet training because the child will be conscious of having passed urine. With diapers, a child is not as aware that anything has happened and may take longer to get trained.

Expert Opinion

For toilet training, the Mayo Clinic advises using an underpad along with training pants, rather than diapers.

Diapers vs. Underpads

While diapers are ideal for young children, underpads may be the solution for older children who may have only the occasional "accident."

References

• Ask Dr. Sears: Toilet Training
• Mayo Clinic: Potty Training: How to Get the Job Done