There are two major employment sectors in the U.S.: public and private. As of 2014, public sector or government jobs accounted for 16 percent of total U.S. employment. Government jobs themselves are found at the federal, state and local or municipal levels, though their numbers pale in comparison to private sector jobs. Government employment is known for its job security and good benefits, with private sector jobs somewhat lagging in terms of pay, benefits and job protections.
Government versus Private Sector Pay
Depending on the level in which one works, meaning federal, state or local, pay for government jobs can be relatively good. The Washington Post, for example, found that 2012 median salary for a federal employee was $74,714 while the Cato Institute says the average 2012 wage for a federal worker was $81,704. By comparison, Cato found that private sector jobs pay an average salary of $54,995. Government workers at the state and local levels also earn similarly attractive pay in many instances.
Government versus Private Sector Benefits
The Cato Institute notes that government jobs offer superior benefits when matched up against their private sector counterparts. Federal workers, for instance, receive pension plans, health insurance, retirement health benefits and retirement savings plans with matching government payments. Government employees at all levels also tend to earn generous holiday and vacation schedules, disability benefits, incentive payments and other perks. Overall, federal employees' average benefits amount to $33,271 versus average benefits of $10,921 paid in private sector jobs.
Employee Job Protections
Some government workers as well as private sector workers are covered by a collective bargaining agreement, or union contract. Collective bargaining agreements feature a measure of job protection, especially against arbitrary termination or lay-off decisions. Union membership as a percentage of total workforce is also higher in the public versus private sector, which has seen union rolls steadily decline to only 6.7 percent. Government jobs also benefit from traditionally strong civil service protections regardless of any collective bargaining agreement.
Making a Decision
If you're a high school graduate or lower and meet a government job's employment requirements, consider applying for the job offered. Those with high school diplomas or less earn 21 percent more in federal government jobs than similar private-sector workers. Overall, government workers were paid 20 percent more in 2012 than private-sector workers in similar fields. If you have a doctoral or professional level degree, however, you'll earn 23 percent more in the private sector than you would working for the government.
- Congressional Research Service: Selected Characteristics of Private and Public Sector Workers
- The Washington Post: Despite Salary Rate Freeze, Average Federal Salary Rises
- Cato Institute: Overpaid Federal Workers
- Congressional Budget Office: Comparing the Compensation of Federal and Private-Sector Employees
- Bureau of Labor Statistics: Union Members -- 2013
- Photo Credit Vladone/iStock/Getty Images
State Jobs vs. Private Jobs
Examples include working in retail, ... Jobs in the private sector may offer bountiful opportunities for entry-level employment, but steep competition for...
How to File a Complaint With the Postmaster General
... (who are far overpaid in comparison to private sector jobs), I am offended and outraged by the treatment I have received...
The Advantages and Disadvantages of Private Sector Work
Private sector jobs have their pros and cons. Impressive salary packages, faster promotions and the opportunity to be on the cutting edge...
Government Employees vs. Private Employees
Jobs in the private sector also have a few benefits that government jobs cannot provide. Other People ... more employees deal with...
Public Sector Jobs Vs. Private Sector Jobs
Public sector jobs are any employment opportunities provided by the government that include areas such as education and public safety; private sector...
What Is a Public Sector Company?
Private Sector Jobs; Advantages & Disadvantages of a Public Company; Private Sector vs. Public Sector Employee Rights; Comments. ... Private Corporation Examples.
Private Corporation Examples
Private Corporation Examples; X. Must See: Slide Shows. Private Corporation Examples. ... Private sector jobs have their pros and cons. Impressive salary...
The Average Starting Salary for Firefighters
States that had the highest job concentration of firefighters include Alaska, Massachusetts, ... Detectives work in either the public or the private...
Careers in Biochemistry
For example, a biochemist in the private sector may work on creating a new soft drink, ... jobs in the biological sciences...
The Advantages of State Employment
Public sector employment involves working for the government at a state or local government level. Private sector jobs are traditionally considered to...
Private Sector vs. Public Sector Employee Rights
Public Sector Jobs Vs. Private Sector Jobs. The Rights of Employees. California Public Sector Labor Laws. Public Sector Management Training. Public Sector...