In a trial -- whether civil or criminal -- lawyers use evidence to try and prove to a judge or jury that their side should prevail. Evidence comes in a wide variety of forms, ranging from bank records or photographs to a murder weapon or witness testimony. Just as it varies in form, evidence also varies in importance. That which is most important to the issues in a case is called material evidence.
Importance of Evidence
Evidence is material if it is important to deciding a case and is directly related to proving some issue raised during trial. For example, in a murder trial, where the victim died from a .38 caliber gunshot wound, a .38 caliber handgun with the defendant's fingerprints on it would be material evidence. It would link the defendant, the gun and the victim.
Evidence in Criminal Appeals
In a criminal case, certain evidence can mean the difference between freedom and incarceration for a defendant. Occasionally, evidence does not make it into trial because it was hidden or not disclosed by the prosecutor. If the defendant appeals his conviction -- asks a higher court to review the trial -- in a case where the prosecutor withheld evidence, the appeals court decides if the evidence not introduced at trial would likely have changed the result. One example of such evidence is a credible witness who identified someone other than the defendant as the person who committed the crime. Evidence that probably would have changed the outcome of a criminal trial is called material evidence.
- Nolo.com: Nolo's Plain English Law Dictionary
- Justia: Supreme Court: Kyles v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 419 (1995)
- Justia: Supreme Court: United States v. Bagley, 473 U.S. 667 (1985)
- "Black's Law Dictionary," 9th ed; Bryan Garner, ed.; 2009; p. 638
- Photo Credit Sean Gallup/Getty Images News/Getty Images
Types of Evidence Law
In law, items are presented to establish, prove or disprove a material fact. These items are referred to as evidence and can...
What Is Substantial Evidence in Law?
What Is Material Evidence? What is Substantial Evidence When Determining Probable Cause? Foundations of Evidence Law; Comments You May Also Like.
Law of Evidence
A trial's goal is to determine, as far as possible, the truth about a matter in dispute. Accordingly, evidence (information offered to...
Difference Between Evidence & Proof
Courts decide on a case by case basis what evidence is material to a case. In court there are two kinds of...
Evidence Based Research Definition
Legal research involves studying previously decided cases, examining evidence and compiling material that will support or disprove a case. ... for example,...
How to Defeat a Motion for Summary Judgment
Gather and submit evidence. ... judgment the non-moving party should gather evidence that proves there are disputes about material facts of the...
What Is Materiality in Accounting Information?
Materiality is the accounting concept relating to the importance or significance of a financial transaction or accounting misstatement. This concept is measured...
How to Collect Evidence at a Crime Scene
What Materials Are Needed to Collect Evidence at a Crime Scene? Featured. 6 Ways to Travel on the Cheap. Read Article. 18...
How to Copyright Material
A copyright acknowledges the rights of the creator of materials such as written works, computer software and photographs. Having a copyright provides...